The Chlorite in the third millennium BC: New insights into the Mineralogy, Geochemistry and Montanarchaeology of the Chlorite Stones from Konar Sandal in Jiroft and the Faryab Mines in Kerman

Document Type : Original Article

Authors

1 Art University of Isfahan, Isfahan, Iran

2 Department of Archaeology, University Tehran, Tehran, Iran

Abstract
Introduction

This paper deals with the chlorite stones obtained from the latest archeological researches at the Konar Sandal site, Jiroft in order to determining the chemical and mineralogical composition and identifying their provenance. The chlorite objects are the most distinctive cultural material from the Jiroft civilization (generally dated back to the third millennium BC). These luxury items have been recognized as an indicator of the connections and interactions in southwest Asia during Bronze Age. Scholars of the ancient Near East have long recognized that the Iranian plateau was a source for these valuable materials. Although the soft green chlorite objects have been found in a wide range from the Indian subcontinent to northern Mesopotamia, these finds were produced in the Halil River Basin for local utilization rather than export. In this paper, some fragments of chlorite vessels recovered from the plundered graveyard of Konar Sandal South are chosen for archaeometric analyses. Also, some samples from newly found mines of the Faryab region (south of the Jiroft plain) have been analyzed for the provenance of the ancient objects of Konar Sandal.



Methods and Results

Petrological and petrographical methods, X-ray diffraction (XRD) and X-ray fluorescence (XRF) and inductively coupled plasma optical emission spectroscopy (ICP-OES) were used to identify the mineralogical and geochemical structure of chlorites and the possible relationship of these materials with the chlorite mines in the Faryab region. Clustering of the results will be interpreted through statistical methods. Polarizd light microscope has been used inorder to characterize the fabrication and texture of the stones in both plane polarized and cross polarized light. For determining the crystalline phase constituents powder patterns of rocks were measured. The characterization of the crystalline phases of the rocks (QXRD), allows the classification of the samples by the different structures. X-ray flouresence has used for the determination of the bulk chemical composition of the rocks. The major, minor and trace elements measured as oxides, and the correlation between the main oxide constituents tend to allow a good classification of the archaeological samples to the stones from the mines. An ICP-MS (inductively coupled plasma mass spectrometry) systems has used to undertake an analytical technique that can be used to measure elements at trace levels in some archaeological and stones from the mines.



Results and Discussion

Iconography, production, provenance, exchange and circulation of chlorite vessels have been topic of many researches in the recent decades. Philip Kohl has deeply studied these studies. Philip Kohl has conducted various studies based on physical and chemical analyses on carved and uncarved samples of chlorite from Tepe Yahya and from outcrops or source samples collected in the mountains immediately north and west of the site and from these vessels found on sites stretching from Mesopotamia into south-western Iran (Susa) and across the Iranian plateau. His studies demonstrated that most of the vessels carved in this distinctive style were indeed made of chlorite and not the related soft stone steatite to which they had been mistakenly attributed. Another archaeometric analysis on the resource of chlorite in the Jiroft region was done by Emami and his colleagues (2017) which resulted in identifying some ancient mines in the western mountains of the Jiroft region which were used by the craftsmen of Konar Sandal. The present research on the chlorite mines of the south of Jiroft region, particularly the Faryab region, introduced new mines which could be used by the craftsmen of the Jiroft civilization in the early Bronze Age. Interestingly, similarities in the mineralogical and geochemical composition of chlorites obtained from Konar Sandal South graveyard and Faryab mines introduce the Faryab mineralogical zone in the south of Kerman as one of the provenances this stone. It seems that further geo-archaeological investigations can identify more ancient mines and mineralogical zones of chlorite in the Kerman Province.



Conclusion

Investigated chlorite objects and stones were examined in order to find any relationship between Konar Sandal and rock samples from Sikhoran mine and Nazari mine in central Faryab orogeny (Mehrouiyeh). On the basis of chemical analysis and measurement of trace elements by XRF and ICP methods, as well as petrology and phase studies, it was determined that Faryab mine played a key role for fabrication of these chlorite stones in the third millennium. Analytical results have approved that the amount of major oxides e.g. MgO and FeO, as well as minor elements e.g. Ca, P, Ti, Sr, were to be an essential factor for clustering of the materials and their origin.

The distinctive features of the quarried stone from Faryab district assumed in good potential correlation with the analyzed samples from south Konar Sandel Cemetery (especially in the M4 and M3 samples). The result is reliable with the results of XRD analysis and thin section petrography of the samples. XRD phase analysis of the rocks from the mines were assumed that the rocks mostly consist of clinochlore, tephrite, spinel and olivine, which have obviously approved the same phase composition within the samples of south Konar Sandal cemetery. Based on petrography, mineralogical and textural observations, the rocks of the region are mainly composed of magnesium-containing olivines, serpentine peridotites and sometimes opaque particles with spinel chemical composition, e.g., magnetite and chromspinel.

The extension of producing and trade of chlorite from southeast to the Punjab valley of Pakistan can be expressed by means of excessive diversity regarding the condition of metamorphism (hydrothermal and proximity) of the chlorite rocks in the southeast of Iranian plateau. In this case, the rock feeding source for the production of chlorite stone artefacts and containers in Halil Rood area is much more diverse than what we know. However, since the Faryab mines are located in an area as cross-cultural bridge between the Persian Gulf to Mesopotamia, the importance of influential economic factors, trade and exchange of chlorite is among the most important case studies in the third millennium BC Iran.

Keywords

Subjects


آمیه، پیر، (1385)، مهرهای آرکائیک شهر سوخته، مجموعه مقالات پیش از تاریخ سیستان: بهکوشش موریتسیو توزی، مترجم: رضا مهرآفرین، سیستان: پایگاه میراث فرهنگی شهر سوخته، صص 470-497.
امامی، سید محمد امین، (1396)، مروری بر فلزگری کُهن مس (آرکئومتالورژی مس) در منطقه هَلیل رود (براساس داده های حاصل از پتروگرافی و ژئوشیمی سرباره های ذوب فلز باستانی)، مطالعات باستان شناسی پارسه، سال اول، شماره ۱، ص 99-111.
اسکندری، نصیر، ویداله، ماسیمو، مسگر، علی اکبر، شفیعی، مژگان، شهسواری، میثم، دوسه، فرانسوا، عابدی، اکبر، انجم روز، سلمان و شهدادی، علی، (1399)، تمدن جیرفت (براساس متون میخی بین النهرینی و کشفیات باستان شناختی در محوطه های باستانی ورامین و کنارصندل جیرفت)، تاریخ اسلام و ایران، شماره ۴۷ (پیاپی ۱۳۷)، ص 11 29.
اسکندری، نصیر، (1399)، نتایج پروژه ی پیش از تاریخ محوطه ی ورامین: معرفی مرحله ی اولیه ی تمدن جیرفت، فصلنامه علمی مطالعات باستان شناسی پارسه، شماره 13، صص 27-53.
پرو، ژان، (1387)، شکل شناسی جیرفت، مجموعه مقالات نخستین همایش بین المللی تمدن حوزه هلیل: جیرفت (1383)، به کوشش: دکتر یوسف مجیدزاده، تهران: سازمان میراث فرهنگی، صنایع دستی و گردشگری استان کرمان، صص،287-294.
پیتمن، هالی، (1384)، هنر عصر مفرغ جنوب شرق ایران،سیای جنوب غربی و دره‌ی سند، مترجم:کوروش روستایی،تهران: پیشین پژوه و مهر بردیا.
حاکمی، علی، (1348)، بررسی‌های باستان‌شناسی حاشیه دشت لوت، مجله باستان‌شناسی و هنر ایران، ش.2، انتشارات وزارت فرهنگ و هنر ایران. اداره کل باستان‌شناسی فرهنگ عامه، صص 51-36.
حصاری،مرتضی؛ پیران، صدیقه، (1384)، فرهنگ حاشیه هلیل رود و جیرفت کاتالوگ نمایشگاه گزیده‌ای از اشیاء استردادی 1384، تهران: موزه‌ی ملی ایران
رازانی، مهدی، امامی، سید محمد امین، مجیدزاده، یوسف، (۱۳۹۰)، بررسی مقدماتی روش ساخت و تزئین سنگ های کلریتی حوزه ی تمدنی هلیل رود. مجموعه مقالات دومین گردهمایی گنجینه های از یاد رفته ی هنر ایران به کوشش مهدی مکینژاد (جلد ۴). تهران:فرهنگستان هنر و متن (موسسه ی تالیف و ترجمه و نشر آثار هنری).
رازانی، مهدی، (1388)، بررسی های آرکئومتریک سنگ های سیاه تمدن جیرفت، پایان‌نامه کارشناسی ارشد، گرایش مرمت اشیاء تاریخی و فرهنگی، دانشگاه هنر اصفهان
سیدسجادی، سید منصور، (1387)، منابع تأمین سنگ لاجورد جیرفت باتوجه به آخرین یافته‌های باستان‌شناسی در شهر سوخته، مجموعه مقالات نخستین همایش بین المللی تمدن حوزه هلیل: جیرفت (1383)، به کوشش: دکتر یوسف مجیدزاده، تهران: سازمان میراث فرهنگی، صنایع دستی و گردشگری استان کرمان، صص340-315.
فرانکفورت، هانری پال، (1387)، سنگ‌های سیاه و هنر در کرمان و آسیای مرکزی، چکیده مقالات همایش بین‌المللی جیرفت، حوزه تمدنی هلیل‌رود، فرهنگستان هنر.
لمبرگ کارلوسکی، کارل، (1387)، قلمرو کنش متقابل در خاور نزدیک باستان: سی سال بعد، مجموعه مقالات نخستین همایش بین المللی تمدن حوزه هلیل، به کوشش: دکتر یوسف مجیدزاده، تهران: سازمان میراث فرهنگی، صنایع دستی و گردشگری استان کرمان، صص423-431.
مجیدزاده، یوسف. (۱۳۸۰)، آیا آرت خاستگاه تمدن سومری است؟ مدارک جدید از کنارهی هلیل رود: استان کرمان مجله ی باستان شناسی و تاریخ ۱۶ (۱): ۳-۱۳.
مجید زاده، یوسف، (1382)، دومین فصل حفریات باستانشناختی در جیرفت در و بهمن 1382، نامه پژوهشگاه میراث فرهنگی،شماره پنجم،زمستان،دوره نخست،شماره پیاپی5،صص78-65.
مجید زاده، یوسف، (1386)، گزارشی کوتاه از پنجمین فصل حفریات باستان‌شناختی در محوطه‌های کنار صندل و گورستان‌های محطوط آباد و قلعه کوچک: جیرفت1385، گزارش‌های باستانشناسی، تهران: سازمان میراث فرهنگی، صنایع دستی و گردشگری، معاونت پژوهشی.
Badrzadeh, Z., T. J. Barrett, J. M. Peter, D. Gimeno, M. Sabzehei, and M. Aghazadeh, 2011, Geology, mineralogy, and sulfur isotope geochemistry of the Sargaz Cu–Zn volcanogenic massive sulfide deposit, Sanandaj–Sirjan Zone, Iran, Mineralium Deposita, 46(8) 905-923.
David, H., 1996, Styles and evolution: Soft stone vessels during the Bronze Age in the Oman Peninsula: Proceedings of the Seminar for Arabian Studies, p. 31-46.
De Cardi, B., 1968, Excavations at Bampūr, SE Iran: A Brief Report, Iran, 6(1), 135-155.
Deer, W. A., J. Bowles, R. A. Howie, D. Vaughan, and J. Zussman, 2011, Rock-forming Minerals: Non-silicates: oxides, hydroxides and sulphides. Volume 5A.
Desset, F., M. Vidale, N. A. Solaimani, E. Battistella, and A. Daneshi, 2017, A Grave of the Halil Rud Valley (Jiroft, Iran, ca. 2400–2200 BC): Stratigraphy, Taphonomy, Funerary Practices, Iranica Antiqua, 52, 25-60.
Emami, M., and A. Parvaresh, 2016, Mineralogish, Petrochemische Untersuchungen an Kupferschlacken aus „SHEIKH-ALI“ Ophiolithkupferlagerstaetten, Kerman, Iran: Archäometrie und Denkmalpflege 2016, p. 205-208.
Emami, M., M. Razani, N. A. Soleimani, and Y. Madjidzadeh, 2017, New insights into the characterization and provenance of chlorite objects from the Jiroft civilization in Iran, Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, 16, 194-204.
Eskandari, N., 2017, Excavations at the Prehistoric Sites of Tepe Dehno and Tepe East Dehno, Shahdad, South-eastern Iran. Iranian Journal of Archaeological Studies, 7(1), 16-33.
Evans, B., and S. Guggenheim, 1988, Talc, pyrophyllite, and related minerals, Reviews in Mineralogy and Geochemistry, 19(1), 225-294.
Field, H., 1933, Steatite Vases from Kish, Antiquity, 7(25), 84-85.
Ghorbani, M., 2013, The economic geology of Iran: mineral deposits and natural resources, Springer Science & Business Media.
Hakemi, A., 1997, Kerman: the original place of production of chlorite stone objects in the 3rd millennium BC, East and West, 47(1/4), 11-40.
Hauptmann, A., 1985, Die Entwicklung der Kupfermetallurgie vom 3 Jahrtausend bis zum Neuzeit 5000 Jahre Kupfer in Oman, 1.
Kohl, P. L., 1974. Seeds of Upheaval: the production of chlorite at Tepe Yahya and an analysis of commodity production and trade in Southwest Asia in the mid-third millennium, Ph.D. dissertation,
Department of Anthropology, Harvard University.
Kohl, P. L., 1976, "Steatite" Carvings of the Early Third Millennium BC, American journal of archaeology, 80(1), 73-75.
Kohl, P. L., 1977, A note on chlorite artefacts from Shahr-i Sokhta, East and West, 27(1/4), 111-127.
Kohl, P. L., G. Harbottle, and E. V. Sayre, 1979, Physicl and Chemical Analyses of Soft Stone Vessels from Southwest Asia, Archaeometry, 21(2), 131-159.
Lamberg-Karlovsky, C., 1988, The" Intercultural style" carved vessels, Iranica Antiqua, 23, 45.
Lamberg-Karlovsky, C., and P. L. Kohl, 1971, The Early Bronze Age of Iran as seen from Tepe Yahya, Expedition, 13(3), 14.
Lamberg-Karlovsky, C. C., 1970, Excavations at Tepe Yahya, Iran, 1967-1969: Progress Report, v. 1, American School of Prehistoric Research, Harvard University.
Madjidzadeh, Y., and H. Pittman, 2008, Excavations at Konar Sandal in the region of Jiroft in the Halil Basin: first preliminary report (2002–2008), Iran, 69-103.
Majidzadeh, Y., B. Ali, and A. ASADI, 2003, Jiroft discovery stuns archaeologists.
Masjedi Khak, P., N. Shirazi, H. Nami, and M. Hajivaliei, 2018, Structural Characterization of Steatite Vessels of Shadyakh by XRF, XRD and SEM Techniques, Journal of Research on Archaeometry, 4(2), 49-60.
Mousivand, F., E. Rastad, J. M. Peter, and S. Maghfouri, 2018, Metallogeny of volcanogenic massive sulfide deposits of Iran, Ore Geology Reviews, 95 974–1007.
Okrusch, M., and S. Matthes, 2010, Einführung und Grundbegriffe, in Mineralogie, 1-43, Springer.
Perrot, J., & Madjidzadeh, Y., 2003, Découvertes récentes à Jiroft (Sud du plateau iranien)(note d'information). Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres, 147(3), 1087-1102.
Potts, T. F., 1993, Patterns of trade in thirdmillennium BC Mesopotamia and Iran, World Archaeology, 24(3), 379-402.
Rastad, E., A. M. Miralipour, and M. Momenzadeh, 2002, Sheikh-Ali copper deposit, a Cyprus-type VMS deposit in Southeast Iran, Journal of Sciences Islamic Republic of Iran, 13(1), 51-64.
Seki, Y., and Y. Oki, 1969, Wairakite-analcime solid solutions from low-grade metamorphic rocks of the Tanzawa Mountains, Central Japan, Mineralogical Journal, 6(1-2), 36-45.